Sole vs NordicTrack vs Bowflex: Comfort Comparison Guide

If you're weighing an elliptical comparison of Sole, NordicTrack, and Bowflex, you're likely stuck between marketing hype and conflicting reviews. You want low-impact cardio that actually fits your cramped apartment, your joint quirks, and your exhaustion after work, not another dust-collecting relic. I've been there: after a wrist injury forced me off kettlebells, I rebuilt my routine on a single elliptical in a one-bedroom with zero setup friction. Sustainable comfort isn't indulgence; it's the shortest path to consistency. Let's cut through the noise with a step-by-step guide focused on what actually matters for daily use. Your future self will thank you.

Why This Comparison Isn't About Specs (It's About Your Body)

Before diving into models, understand each brand's elliptical philosophy. This shapes everything from step-up height to how you'll feel after 10 minutes: If you're unsure why some machines feel smoother than others, see our front vs rear-drive comfort for long-term comfort insights.

• Sole: "Quiet simplicity first." Their machines prioritize smooth, predictable motion with minimal electronics. Think hydraulic handrails, analog resistance dials, and footpaths that rarely wobble. Best for: Those who hate subscriptions, want to train while watching Netflix, or need to placate downstairs neighbors.
• NordicTrack: "Tech-driven motivation." iFIT integration auto-adjusts incline/resistance while trainers shout encouragement. Screens dominate the console. Best for: Gamification lovers or those who need external accountability (but only if you'll actually use the subscription).
• Bowflex: "Space-saving engineering." They compress commercial-grade builds into shockingly narrow footprints. Often feature hybrid movements (elliptical + stepper). Best for: Studio apartments or multi-room homes where floor space is non-negotiable.

Verbatim allusion: Small, repeatable wins turn cardio into a lifelong habit.

Your First Step: Match Your Body to the Machine

Forget advertised "stride lengths." What matters is how the elliptical feels for your inseam. Taller users can skip guesswork with our best ellipticals for tall users. Follow this:

1. Measure your inseam (floor to crotch while standing barefoot).

2. Find your ideal stride range:

   • Under 30": Look for ≤18" stride (e.g., Sole E25, Bowflex Max Trainer M5)
   • 30-34": Target 18-20" (NordicTrack AirGlide 14i's 17.8-18.5")
   • Over 34": Demand ≥20" (Sole E35, NordicTrack Commercial X16)

3. Test step-up height before buying. If it's over 14", you'll need clearance for a full stride, critical for basements or 8-ft ceilings. NordicTrack's AirGlide 14i sits low (12.5"), while many Sole models hit 15".

YOSUDA 3-in-1 Elliptical exercise machine

Versatile 3-in-1 elliptical for effective, quiet, space-saving home workouts.

$391.98

4.3

Noise Level26 dB (Library Quiet)

Buy on Amazon

Noise Level26 dB (Library Quiet)

Pros

3-in-1: Elliptical, Climber, Stepper for varied workouts.

Whisper-quiet magnetic system (26 dB) ideal for shared spaces.

Compact footprint (38"x21") saves at least 20% space.

Cons

Build quality receives mixed feedback (some find it flimsy).

15.5-inch stride might feel short for taller users.

Customers find this elliptical machine to be a good quality exercise machine that's easy to assemble with included tools and provides a challenging workout. They appreciate its quiet operation, space-saving footprint, and consider it great value for money. The build quality receives mixed feedback, with some finding it solid while others describe it as flimsy.

Customers find this elliptical machine to be a good quality exercise machine that's easy to assemble with included tools and provides a challenging workout. They appreciate its quiet operation, space-saving footprint, and consider it great value for money. The build quality receives mixed feedback, with some finding it solid while others describe it as flimsy.

Show more

Buy on Amazon

Why Handle Comfort Makes or Breaks Consistency

Handles should feel like a handshake, not a chore. Most brands hide crucial details:

• Sole: Padded stationary handles + moving bars with rubber grips. Ideal for: Users with grip sensitivity (arthritis, wrist strain). No buttons on handles, pure focus on movement.
• NordicTrack: Slim wrapped bars with resistance/incline buttons on the grips. Caution: Reviewers note the AirGlide 14i's screen forces downward posture during inclines, straining necks for shorter users.
• Bowflex: Shorter grip range (harder for tall users to find neutral spine). Max Trainers use arm-swivels that mimic stair climbing (great for upper-body engagement but challenging for shoulder issues).

Pro Tip: If your wrists tweak during testing, skip it. Comfort isn't negotiable.

Space and Noise: The Apartment-Tested Reality Check

You're not living in a gym studio. Address these before unboxing:

Footprint & Ceiling Clearance: Avoid the "Oh No" Moment

Measure twice. Most brands list footprint without stride extension. Add 6" front/back for natural motion. If space is tight, compare trade-offs in our compact elliptical guide. For tight spaces:

• Bowflex Max Trainer M9: 67"L x 30"W (narrowest in class)
• Sole E25: 70"L x 28"W (but 15" step-up height)
• NordicTrack AirGlide 14i: 68"L x 31"W (12.5" step-up, best for low ceilings)

Check your ceiling height during max incline. At 15% incline, your head swings higher. If you're 5'8"+, test this with the retailer.

Noise Levels: The Neighbor Approval Test

Real-world dB ratings are scarce, but here's what users report after 6 months:

Key insight: NordicTrack's auto-incline motors (like on the AirGlide 14i) create audible thuds (not mentioned in specs). A $25 rubber mat fixes 80% of vibration issues. For specific mat and setup picks, see our elliptical accessories guide.

The Habit Sustainability Audit

Is this machine designed for daily use? Run this checklist:

Decision Fatigue Killers

• Presets: Sole saves 6 user profiles without apps. NordicTrack requires iFIT ($39/yr) for personalized plans. Bowflex uses app presets only.
• Startup friction: NordicTrack's 14" touchscreen takes 45+ seconds to boot. Sole/Bowflex are ready in 5.
• Metrics: Does it show only what you need? (Time, calories, heart rate). Cluttered consoles = skipped workouts.

Multi-User Reality

For couples with height gaps (e.g., 5'2" and 6'1"):

• Adjustability wins: NordicTrack's moving handles adapt mid-stride. Sole's fixed rails require manual height tweaks.
• Stride tolerance: Bowflex's hybrid motion accommodates wider ranges, but sacrifices pure elliptical smoothness.

Critical test: Have both partners try it back-to-back. If the shorter one feels strained, it won't last 3 months.

Final Verdict: Which Fits Your Life?

Who Should Choose Which

• Pick Sole if:

  • You value silence and simplicity over bells/whistles.
  • Space allows for slightly taller step-up height.
  • You'll use it without subscriptions (e.g., while watching TV).
  • Top model: Sole E25 ($1,199) - indestructible build, 20" stride, 300-lb capacity.

• Pick NordicTrack if:

  • iFIT's guided workouts genuinely motivate you.
  • You have ceiling height for inclines (or choose low-step models like AirGlide 14i).
  • Screen position won't force bad posture.
  • Top model: AirGlide 14i ($1,599) - immersive incline, quiet pedals, but only if you use iFIT.

• Pick Bowflex if:

  • Floor space is tighter than 30" width.
  • You want hybrid motion (elliptical + stepper).
  • Tech integration is secondary to footprint.
  • Top model: Max Trainer M9 ($1,999) - compact powerhouse, but narrow stride may frustrate taller users.

The Non-Negotiables for Lasting Habits

Regardless of brand:

• Step-up height must be ≤13" for apartments/basements.
• Handle grips need texture (not slippery plastic).
• Startup time under 10 seconds (or you'll skip sessions).
• No mandatory subscriptions for core metrics (time/calories).

Your Next Move: Start Tiny, Stay Consistent

Buy the machine that clears your space and body hurdles first. Perfection is the enemy of consistency. My wrist healed, but I kept that elliptical because it asked for nothing, just 12 minutes before coffee. Set non-negotiables: zero setup time, sessions shorter than your attention span. Press start. Feel the pedals. Breathe. That's how you build sustainable habit design. Your future self will thank you.